Guide to Superior AI Beef Bulls
Breed improvement through the selection and widespread use of superior breeding stock is one of the most cost effective means of improving the efficiency of beef production. Once genetic improvement is made it is permanent and cumulative from one generation to the next while effective breeding programmes are in place. For example, the difference in carcase value between the male progeny of the top Charolais AI bull and the bottom Charolais AI bull at slaughter is estimated to come to about €80.
Selection of better quality female breeding stock adds further value to progeny although over a longer time frame.
Bull Evaluation
Currently, in AI there is a stock of beef bulls that have been put through the progeny test programme and are listed available for widespread use. The progeny test provides information on growth rate, carcase conformation, carcase leanness and kill out percentage.
Calving surveys provide essential data on the level of calving difficulty associated with a bull.
Expected Progeny Differences (EPD's)
The evaluations of the commercially important traits such as growth and carcase conformation are expressed as Expected Progeny Differences (EPD's). All EPD's are referenced to a Holstein/Friesian base. Therefore, a bull's EPD for growth is the difference in kg of carcase between the steer progeny (slaughtered at approximately 26 months of age) of the particular test bull and progeny of standard Holstein/Friesian parents reared under the same conditions and slaughtered at the same age. For example, if a Charolais bull has a "Growth EPD" of 50 kg it indicates that the carcases of his steer progeny from Holstein/Friesian cows are expected to be 50kg heavier than standard Holstein/Friesian steers at 26 months of age. The average weight of the Holstein/ Friesian carcases in the progeny test programme was 350kg.
Conformation scores are converted to a numeric scale. Thus grades EUROP are converted to 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 respectively. The average conformation of the Holstein/Friesian test steers was 2.02 or slightly to in the O grade. Therefore, a beef bull showing a conformation EPD of 1.0 is expected to produce steer progeny from Holstein/Friesian cows of conformation score 3.02 or slightly into the R grade.
Linear Scoring and BLUP
Not all bulls in AI have been or can be progeny tested. Fortunately, the development of linear scoring in the Limousin, Charolais and Simmental Pedigree herds provides very useful information on the breeding values for muscling, size and functional traits. Trained technicians score animals at approximately 7 months of age for muscular development, skeletal development, functional traits (legs, joints, etc) and breed characteristics. These linear scores plus the values on the bulls relatives (ancestors, siblings and progeny) can then be subjected to the BLUP technique for genetic evaluation to generate predicted breeding values for the measured traits. In some cases predicted 200 day and 400 day weights are also available.
The breeding values are usually expressed in index form. The index has been scaled to a mean of 100. In the case of Charolais, Simmental and Limousin the current base year is 1995. The base year is changed periodically.
With genetic progress the average of calves born in succeeding years will improve. For example, in the case of Charolais, the average of calves born in 2001 is 108 for muscle and 105 for skeletal and for Simmental the average of 2001 born calves is 105 for muscle and 102 for skeletal. In the case of Limousin, the average for 2001 born calves in 108 for muscle, 106 of skeletal, 104 for functionality and 105 for docility.
Reliability
All predicted breeding values should be read in conjunction with the associated reliability score, which is an indication of the amount of confidence that can be placed in the figures.
Young bulls with no progeny assessed will typically have a reliability rating of 30% to 45%. A mature bull in AI with large numbers of progeny scored is likely to have a reliability rating of over 80% in which case the actual performance of the progeny will be close to the predicted performance.
Bull Selection
In selecting bulls for use in suckler herds, producers should examine the published information (progeny test results, BLUP scores and calving survey data) and make choices on the traits that will yield the best returns or strengthen some weakness on the dam side.
No bull should be widely used in commercial herds without a calving survey. Part-time farmers will be conscious of calving difficulty, whereas full-time farmers with good calving skills and adequate supervision may risk higher calving difficulty to achieve butter quality calves.
Growth rate is by far the most valuable trait followed by conformation. Weanling producers should place priority on these two characteristics as the production of well shaped high growth rate weanlings will command best market returns. Finishers should put more emphasis on carcase growth than on other traits. The following tables provide breeding information on a selection of the best beef bulls in AI that are widely available.
Guide To Widely Available Superior Beef Bulls In AI
Progeny Tested Bulls
Charolais
|
Name |
AI |
EPD |
BLUP |
% Serious |
|||
|
Growth (kg) |
Conf. Score |
Rel |
Mus |
Ske |
Difficulty* |
||
|
Doonally Fabus Hara Kiri Hallowtree Nicholas Mogador Doonally Feld Doonally Donald Mozart Doonally New Doonally Nicefor Pirate Bova Oniraloin |
CF49 HK1 HWN MDO CF47 CF43 MZT CF52 CF51 PTE BVX |
68.5 61.5 56.2 49.2 49.8 47.5 |
1.15 1.18 1.29 1.16 1.00 1.12 |
92 97
94 94 93 83 96 91 63 61 |
119 126
135 108 105 135 137 112 122 129 |
112 96
107 106 95 101 116 109 109 124 |
5.0 4.0 7.0 4.7 3.3 2.7 4.0 4.3 3.3 4.2 2.0 |
* Bulls with a serious calving % greater than 4.5 are above average for the breed.
Belgian Blue
|
Name |
AI Code |
EPD (Progeny Tested) |
% Serious |
|
|
Growth (kg) |
Conf. Score |
Difficulty * |
||
|
Tin Tin de My Nero Victorieus D'au Chene Hardi de Bove General Samakand Ozymandias Espoir du Jardin |
TIY NRO VDC HRB GUY SOY EDJ |
42.0 37.0 34.3 39.1 27.8 |
1.17 1.22 1.09 1.30 1.25 |
6.5 5.5 5.5 2.6 2.3 3.8 3.6 |
* Bulls with a serious calving % greater than 4.5 are above average for the breed.
Limousin
|
Name |
AI Code |
EPD |
BLUP |
% Serious |
|||
|
Growth (kg) |
Conf. Score |
Rel |
Mus |
Ske |
Calving |
||
|
Barnhill Hamish Nesquick Derg Alan Hortensia Litron Palmeres |
BHH NSQ DGA HTA TON PAM |
21.0 24.5 20.1 |
1.09 0.90 1.08 |
91 54 86 97 95 48 |
103 115 98 129 119 132 |
102 119 86 92 109 100 |
1.6 1.7 3.1 2.7 2.0 3.0 |
Bulls with serious calving difficulty % greater than 3.8 are above average for the breed. Use easy calving bulls on heifers.
Simmental
|
Name |
AI Code |
EPD |
BLUP |
% Serious |
|||
|
Growth (kg) |
Conf. Score |
Rel |
Mus |
Ske |
Calving |
||
|
Feighduff Brendan Suir Con Dovea Disko |
FBX SCO DDI |
29.5 30.3 24.4 |
0.83 0.82 0.84 |
91 |
125 |
86 |
4.0 3.5 1.8 |
Bulls with a calving difficulty % greater than 4.2 are above average for the breed.
Hereford
|
Name |
AI Code |
EPD |
% Serious Calving |
|
|
Growth (kg) |
Conf. Score |
Difficulty |
||
|
Goldfield 1 Superstar Clonakenny Fenton Rathcar Express |
GDS CKT RCE |
26.2 26.6 23.8 |
0.52 0.61 0.62 |
6.1 0.4 0.3 |
Bulls with serious calving difficulty greater than 1.8 are above average for the breed.
Angus
|
Name |
AI Code |
EPD (Progeny Test) |
% Serious Calving |
|
|
Growth (kg) |
Conf. Score |
Difficulty |
||
|
Rainbow Hills Independence Bohey Jasper DMM Distinction 17G Bohey Leo Shankill Max |
117 RHD BJP DMG BEH SKM |
14.8 9.3 |
0.89 0.74 |
3.3 3.5 3.1 1.6 1.2 |
Bulls with serious calving difficulty greater than 2.3 are above average for the breed.
Hereford and Angus beef bulls are used mostly in dairy herds or on beef and dairy heifers. Use bulls with good growth rates and good conformation on dairy cows and easy calving bulls on heifers.
Maternally tested and bulls with good maternal traits available through AI
- French cattle breeding programmes include the testing of selected bulls for their ability to produce good breeding females in the Charolais, Limousin and Blonde d'Aquitaine breeds. Twenty-five heifers of each test sire are kept in a breeding station and measurements taken that produce indices for beefproduction (weight, muscularity and skeletal) fertility (heifers in calf after 3 months) calvingease and milk production.
- Where farmers choose purebred or all beef cross bred replacements they should use maternally tested beef sires to produce replacements.
- Consult your Teagasc advisor or AI technician for more information on maternally tested bulls.
Maternally Tested Charolais
|
Bull Name |
Aboukir |
Indompte |
|
AI Code |
ABK |
INP |
|
Growth Fertility Ease of Calving Milk Muscularity Skeletal Overall Maternal |
135 102 120 113 111 127 119 |
106 116 95 95 119 92 103 |
Maternally Tested Limousin
|
Bull Name |
Ulysse |
Hymour |
Epson |
|
AI Code |
ULE |
HOU |
EPN |
|
Fertility Calving Ease Milk Muscularity Skeletal Functionality Docility Overall Maternal |
101 113 123 124 99 112 106 111 |
105 112 122
108 |
94 118 105 113 111 111 112 105 |
Simmental
There is no maternal testing in the Simmental breed but the following bulls are considered to have strong maternal traits on the basis of progeny or back breeding.
|
Name |
AI Code |
EPD (Progeny Test) |
BLUP Linear Score |
% Serious |
||||
|
Growth kg |
Conf. |
Rel |
Mus |
Ske |
FUN |
Difficulty |
||
|
Hurtig Planet Ballyduff Jeweller Hillcrest King Hillcrest Monty Moltke Marblehill Liam Milton Lord |
HRG AS12 BDJ HKG HLY MTE MLM MIF |
36.3 20.7
32.1
|
0.82 0.72
0.71 |
38
75 39 38
43 41 |
109
136 140 136
143 110 |
111
101 118 118
108 125 |
118
120 111 140
113 119 |
3.8 1.8 6.1
3.2 |
Bulls with serious calving difficulty % greater than 4.2 are above average for the breed. Some do not yet have calving survey results available, check with AI Organisation before use.
The functionality score (FUN) which indicated the quality and correctness of a bulls bone structure, joints, legs, etc. is shown in the above table as it is an important trait in the breeding of replacements.
BLUP scores suggest that some of the bulls listed also have strong terminal beef traits.





